Suggestions

If it’s going to be anything like DIB then the status ailments wear off as soon as a battle ends as opposed to staying until they’re removed. Although it could be useful if there’s anything like Morfeus. I’m not saying that I’m against having potions that remove status ailments, they would be very useful. I just think that potions should be in the game but there should be some restrictions like I mentioned above to avoid the 3 monsters thing

Oh yeah fair point, that would really be a bit of a waste of a potion then wouldn’t it? I dunno, if Hunter Island has a game mechanic where the status effect stays with the monster until it reaches a town or something then it would be useful but yeah I see what you mean.

  1. potions to increase strength: we can do this at the end of the game. level up potions for xxx amount of silver to assist people trying to master the infinite dungeon. is this good enough? 

  2. healing potions: why do we need this? from a game balancing perspective its the same exact thing. If we include potions, we will have to balance the game accordingly (ie make enemy stronger, assuming everyone will use it). Do people actually enjoy using potions? This is something we did not enjoy in a lot of old school rpgs, it gets tedious. Why go that route? We can just balance the game to work without them. We also have healer monsters. As for the save me function (which no one uses), we need to work on something more useful :) 

I was thinking we have 2 tiers of potions, one cost gold and the other silver. I was also thinking that you use the potions before you go into battle, but either way works. I think that the tier health potion or “monster food” as I want to call it would restore 10% of one monsters mad health and the tier 2 could restore maybe 25%, all debatable. As for status potions like anti-sleep I think KiltedCobra stated above would be fine. In regards to status boost potions, you could make them work very similar to x-(insert attack, defense, etc.) in the pokemon games. They give you a boost to their specified area and only last for that battle. And if the devs want they could even implement whole party effecting “spells” or something for 5 times the price of the potion equivalent.

Yes the hp of one monster unless they like the idea of a new item thing I just came up with: monster feast- restores all monsters health by 15-25% of their max health, but is very pricy.
No I do not think a restore all health potion/food would be good because then it would loose strategy and people would just jet a load of those and screw the game up compleatly.
And finally yes if you us a potion it should add maybe 100 time to said monster and go onto the next.

One last thought: in order to keep the game strategic you could limit potion use to 5 potions a day or to 1 potion per active party monster per day.

Do we know yet if spirits will be making an appearance in this game, or some sort of support similar to them?

I haven’t seen anything on the subject, but I would love to see them included in this game too!

Well I don’t know about spirits themselves but maybe, tying in with your above comment and the discussion of whole team affecting spells, maybe you could discover spells in dungeons as opposed to spirits.

As you progressed in the game you would challenge these dungeons and after a boss fight, you would be granted the spell which would increase in effectiveness the more often you used it in battle. Very similar to spirits, I know, but I feel the support was a nice tough and that spirits wouldn’t really necessarily fit in this game.

You would have to put a limiter on it so they are not abused, but I like the idea. I would still like spirits though!

Yeah something like you can only use them so many times before having to return to a town to rest or something.

I don’t really like this potion idea. If a dungeons is too hard, then you just train your monsters and turn everyone of them into super Chuck Norris.

Well once you hit level cap getting through the infinite dungeon becomes really hard after a while.

Didn’t think about that. But they didn’t anounced if there would be an infinite dungeon in HI I think (if they did, slap me in the face).

They did! SLAP!! They announced it during a chat withy the main admin I think you missed. They also fixed the no waypoint after 285(I think that’s when the waypoints stopped) bug, so there will be a waypoint every 5 floors for as far as you can go!

Once the kinks of multiplayer PvP are worked out (as I’m sure there will be a few), how about tournaments or arena events.  You start the event and engage in X number of PvP battles and get a score which you continue to improve throughout the event.  The highest scores get prizes, and like discussed in another thread this should include a WIDE range of high scores like:

1-10: Best prize

11-20: Second best prize

21-100: Third

101-1000: Consolation prize of some sort.  

Figure out a good range to reward…I don’t know…the top 20% of players?  

You should get some sort of points for event entering combat even if you lose so that players are attracted to battling and not wasting their time even if they don’t win much.  

Limit in some way the number of times you can battle, each day, or every 12 hours or something.  Maaaaaybe allow players to pay to speed this up.  I saw this in another game (which I won’t mention again) and there were two ways you could pay.  You could pay one amount to increase your total battle count: like from 5/day to 6/day.  I approved this sort of moneymaking option.   You could also pay to reset the timer and battle your full count again:  I don’t approve of this.  It led to major abuse by people with daddy’s big wallet.  Yes, you may make a lot of money from a very few players, but you would enrage the rest of us.  LOL

I would love a tournament style battle thing! This would be awesome! Of course we would have to give the winner a waffle…

not sure if this has been said before, but here are my suggestions

i was a former player of geomon, and there were many things that geomon had that everyone enjoyed and would benifit this game.

personas. they are basically cosmetic skins you can add to a certian monster, like a red plasmorex. no stat difference, and it would make people be able to personalize their monsters, which many like to do.

chat. chat is chat. people loved the community in geomon and that was one of the main aspects of it.

monsters. they had monsters, but more kept coming. they would release one more after almost every update and it would be a race to see who finds it first. the one who finds one first gets a mention on the news (the ingame news and facebook).

lastly, stats such as atk defense speed luck resistance. it wasnt enough to get simply the best geomon. you needed to have the best stats. so if an average plasmorex hp is 500 (just an example) and someone has a 465 hp one, it would not be worth much, even if the plasomarex is a rare monster. whileas a 540 or 530 hp plasmorex would be considered godly and be worth much more than an ordinary plasmorex. see what im getting at? and rank boosting items would not be a good idea. even if they are rare. it gives people more satisfaction knowing that they hunded for hours and got an s rank monster than having rank boosting items used on the rank below s.

( i have a feeling you guys are tired of hearing about geomon so im just going to end this message here although there is much more to say. if any devs want to know more about geomon just ask me or one of the others who used to play such as jemnidad and blix)

also, i dont really like the cutesy art stlye, although im sure the game will be great, this was what drove alot of geomon players away when loki studios started changing the art to the cutesy style. i like art more like this : classicthrakos_zps9c64b569.png although im sure the game will be great anyways

Regarding chat, I just want to throw this out there.  What I think would be cool would be individual town chat.  Like a portal within each town tavern.  Check out Arcane legends.  There is chat wherever you go, but you only see what other people in that specific area are saying. You chat with people in that town and that town only, so numbers are minimized.  If you want to chat with specific people, you say: “Meet up in XXXX town”  

Certain towns should be designated for Help/Support and indicated as such for new players.  Like a place to go when you are stuck.  In Geomon, as a moderator I usually monitored the Support channel waiting and willing to help anyone who needed game advice.  If there aren’t live moderators then maybe at least the support chat can be logged and reviewed daily by an admin.  JJchen brings up a good point that many players, especially kids, don’t have email and can’t report bugs and support issues except through an in game mechanism.  

Arcane legends doesn’t use live moderators either.  They have an extremely (overly?) tight filtering system.  It won’t even let you say “Push it”.  Or “I can’t get it”.  I think they only allow standard ascii characters. Geomon had issues with players getting around filters by using non-English keyboards that had similar looking letters.   And Arcane has a Report Player button which temporarily disables that player’s chat and repeat offenders get banned.  some sort of arbitration applies if somebody goes around spam Reporting players who are NOT being offensive and the wrongdoer will get banned from the game.  

I know this may be a long way out as a feature to be added, but I hope these ideas get some consideration.  

I think jjchen and jemnidad has lovely suggestions for the chat.

I, personally, do not mind this “cutesy” style. I think it’s crisp, clean, and nice. However, I absolutely adore realistic art as well. So cutesy or realistic, I won’t care, really.

It’s also been repeated quite often that Hunter Island was actually requested to have a cutesy art style, and DIB was supposed to have the realistic art style. But hey, at least they have cool looking monsters too.

*whispers to Kookaburra*  erm, they’re not calling them espers here…that was Geomon.  LOL

I like that HI takes input from the fans for naming the new monsters.  It might be cool after the game is released to make it a contest of sorts. Whoever submits the winning name gets a free S type of that first evolution or something.  If that’s possible.  

Geomon used to release new types but only give hints about it.  People would guess the A) elements and B) type or name and then whoever got those right got a free persona.  Whoever caught the first one in the game after its release got some recognition on Facebook.