Not quite what happened…
After her buff in January I moved her from E tier to B tier and you said she should be A or higher, to which I basically said I think she’s great but trying to find the perfect tier for her I ended up settling on B but am looking for more feedback to decide the exact position. After feedback I moved her to A tier and in the next update I do I’ll be moving her to S- tier. I didn’t re-read the thread but I’m pretty sure there were multiple voices both for and against Nightingale being very strong.