šŸ† Neo Monsters tier list (see first post) šŸ†

That’s the second or third time you’ve ignored my question now.

You write biblical sized texts and expect people to read, but you keep ignoring what I’m asking. I will not engage with you on this matter further as you won’t do me the curtesy of responding to my questions.

I will ask a different mod instead and perhaps get a response.

@GMagic I feel KD should be in the title of the list so that the source is cited within the title. Could this be included in the poll ?

I did just answer it, didn’t I? I said I agreed that… aka yes it’s fine.

What to Sherlocks voting system?

I think what lemon wants is an Option to vote for a renaming of the list? Not sure if I got it right tho

1 Like

Bang on.

I still don’t even get how one mod over rules two on the matter

Because KD is the Mod that moderates the other mods.

Ahh! Yes that one slipped over me while jumping between different chats.

On that I say you’re welcome to your opinion but I think the name of the thread should reside with the one who manages the thread (my own opinion here). So I disagree with it being voted on.

I’d be open to discussing it with the other moderators privately. There are finer points to it which warrant discussion, so I don’t think Sherlock’s and GMagic’s opinion written thus far should be taken as votes just yet.

For example,

  • There is greater value to the community having a clear tier list as ā€œTHE tier listā€.
  • There are personal repercussions for me by having my name plastered on it.
  • The current title has benefits for finding it with searches.
  • If it’s having my name on it, would this mean I take sole ownership of the positions and nobody gets a say (is that what people want?). That, in itself, could have negative repercussions for me in the community.
  • Would having my name on it discourage input from people on where monsters should be.
1 Like

I’m on board with what you’re saying, is it cool if we see what people vote then either put his name on it or don’t? Because if community input wins, it’s not really his list anymore, it’s everyone’s (or at least has the ability to be).

2 Likes

If we make him change the title to killerdog’s tier list, wouldn’t he be able to overrule everyone when he feels like being stubborn about certain placements? It would only be fair if that was the case, but it would also contradict your pushing for polls to settle controversial placements…

that’s exactly what it was from the beginning :joy:

1 Like

Yes. This is why I’m saying it should be one or the other :blush:

Ah, I think you’d be in the vast minority then. Most people would prefer an option to overruled killerdog on controversial issues.

I just think one or the other should happen. @NMEduck

Either it’s has stronger community input therefore can be the official Neo Mon Tier list

Or it stays exactly as the same now, where KD can and does overrule, but it should be titled as his list.

The poll is currently leaning to the former

I also misinterpreted the intentions of the poll since killerdog had already agreed to let polls decide occasional monster placements before the thread was created lmfao

1 Like

You say I overrule like it’s a terrible thing. Man, I have my own opinions and some of them have some value. Sometimes the community is wrong or you’re wrong too. It shouldn’t be a big deal or need a name change of the thread because I choose my own opinion sometimes (I take people’s input into account far more than you realise, that part shouldn’t be in question).

At some point I’d like to see you give constructive input to the same level that you like to tell me I’m doing things wrong.

:popcorn:

1 Like

No I don’t intend to imply it that way. I didn’t say it’s a terrible thing. It’s just a fact that’s all. You do have the final say. It’s pure truth. You have the final say. No misintention there. I’m sorry if the word overrule has triggered you, I can change it to say Final say or something lol.

I just think accuracy is further improved with more minds who have final say, that’s all.

Eeer what?

What have I said you’ve done wrong? (Other than the way you construct your arguments?) After literally just telling you this in DMs, once again I’m now having to respond to something I’ve not said.

I don’t understand. Here’s some sound bites below.

I mean, how on Earth have you reached I tell you you do things wrong from this? This is actually unbelievable.

:popcorn: :popcorn: :popcorn:

It’s because he doesn’t like having any ounce of his power over this whole process completely stripped from him. It’s honestly like a petulant 5 year old who is line leader for the day in Kindergarten having to turn it over to the next Kid as it cycles through the class.

2 Likes